Feed aggregator
Out of Position Review
This is a review is cross posted (after slight editing) from my own LJ. It contains a fair number of spoilers, so it'll be behind a nice big cut.
For those who haven't yet read the blurb on the back of the book/website, or read the first third of the book on the web, or even seen another review by now, the story features the football playing tiger Dev and the crafty cross dressing fox Lee. Lee trips Dev in to bed, and surprise, Dev likes it! This sets up the basic premise of Lee and Dev trying to make their way as a couple in the professional sports world.
The setting is essentially a furry copy of the current modern world, the same universe and time frame as Kyell's previous novel, Waterways. He even goes so far as to map the city names he's created to various locations in the US. It's a well constructed universe, solid and fleshed out. The small school scenes feel very real to me as someone who went to a div III school in the midwest, and the later scenes still kept that feeling of authenticity even as they went into places where I don't have the experience to know any better. The setting never detracted from the story, and mostly blended into the background of the character interaction. It felt like much more of the setting was assumed, unlike the stories set in Argaea (the setting of Volle and it's sequels) where the setting was more explicity described to point out the contrasts between that world and our onw..
It is a very character driven story, and those characters are once again magnificent people who are engaging and likeable even if they do have their own set of flaws.
Dev the tiger is my favorite character in the book, the one that I want waiting for me at home. I did have some issues with his characterization though... While the issues about coming out were very thoroghly explored in Waterways and I don't expect this book to spend all it's time going over the same sort of themes, Dev's acceptance of his own sexuality feels abrupt and rushed. It just came out of the blue after this chance encounter. Dev is confused for a couple weeks, then bam, he's back to get some more from Lee. From then on, he's suddenly ok with being gay, he's just primarily worried about staying in the closet. Has Dev really made it to his junior year of college without an inkling that he liked guys? Is it something he's thought about before but Kyell didn't find the space to tell us?
There's a bit of a time gap in the story, and when it picks back up it felt like a rather abrupt switch had gotten thrown that was not properly explained or explored. There's only a brief pause before Dev is again happily handling Lee. That is a relatively minor quibble for me, as I easily got swept up in the relationship interplay between Dev and Lee, and the progression towards pro football and his efforts to survive and thrive there. Dev is sweet (though he'd probably growl if you called him that) and straightforward. Most of the time it feels like his emotions are buried and restrained, but every so often these moments pop up that just are so beautiful it made me want to cry. In particular I was touched by the scene where he meets Lee's father and deftly short circuits a rather heated argument with his genuine sincerity, as well as a moment toward the end when he asks whether he should be thinking about the future as his or as ours [his and Lee's].
Lee is a more complicated character, though it didn't necessarily feel that way to me. The drive, intelligence and willing to be a bit underhanded at need felt very familiar to me. In a lot of ways we have similar views on commitments, which made his decision to quit school to take the job resonate with me. I don't know that I could have made the same decision as Lee, but I understand exactly what forces were pulling him in each direction. Lee also faded a bit into the background in the final section of the novel. While a critical player, he was often absent, off doing a job that those of us non-sports fans may not really understand. Lee's lack of physical presence was as much a character in the final section as his presence was. It was wonderful story construction and hightened the emotional impact, but it did let his character fade and subtly change (itself an important plot point).
This is an adult novel, and there is plenty of sex. I am happy to report that OOP is in my opinion the hottest of all Kyell's novels so far. For one thing, unlike Waterways, it didn't feature underage characters I felt weird getting aroused over. It also pushed a lot more of my buttons. One thing that did bother me a little was the seeming one sidedness of the sex in the relationship. It always seemed to be the same person taking the same roles. Dev tried oral a couple times and didn't like it... There was never any discussion of any possibility of him bottoming for Lee ever. That stuck out to me, and in a way felt like it was an assumption of Dev's dominance and masculinity, playing into both masculine stereotypes (i.e. big football player couldn't take it up the butt) and furry stereotypes of foxes being submissive. It made their sex life seem rather one dimensional over the course of the novel even if the individual sex scenes were always very well done, and not exactly condusive to being read while in public.
Final thoughts: Overall I really loved this novel. I read it twice from cover to cover on the way home from Further Confusion. It is most definitely worth picking up. I was a little worried about the football, but frankly I needn't have bothered. It's mostly a story about pro athletes in general, and could have been written with baseball, hockey or whatever players instead. The football action that is there is written in an aproachable manner, but still meaty enough (I hope) for actual football fans. It's the complete package in a furry novel, and I'm betting that it's going to be the furry novel of the year.
Final [Spoilery] Thoughts: Something about the ending that bothered me in retrospect was that it felt cribbed from the Ironman movie. While reading it, everything felt right and good, but after putting the book down, for a bit I thought that the whole press-conference revelation and quick end felt rather familiar, and realized that it was almost exactly like the end of Ironman with Tony Stark poised to issue a denial, then throwing caution to the wind and bursting out his secret. It was still a blockbuster moment for me, and nearly brought me to tears both times on the plane, even if it wasn't unexpected. One other thing that bothered me was the casual drinking and driving. While it may be in character (I'm from Cincinnati, I know how those things can go) it still worried me. I lost a friend in high school to a drunk driver, and that kind of thing bothers me.
Semi-unrelated note: I have read speculation that the first pro athlete to come out while active will likely be a solid 'franchise' player or backup who is still active but approaching the end of their productive career. It wouldn't be a big name, but someone who's worked hard, hasn't made a huge impact in any kind of record books but sees an opportunity to make a name for themselves by coming out prior to retirement. I do think there is also a plausible alternative scenario with the changing environment. I could see the first out active pro athlete as someone who has been out throughout their playing career, from high school through college and into the pros. That would be someone who was a natural and truly gifted athlete, a star who's talent ensures they cannot be overlooked by recruiters, but who stepped out of the closet such a long time ago that there would be no 'coming out' press because that happened so long ago that it faded into a non-issue.
Tangentially related note: On CNN headlines the other day there was a story about the progressive brain damage players in the NFL suffer due to repeated concussions and playing through concussions. That made me really worry about Dev, as he's the kind of player (at least right now) who would be very likely to suffer a concussion as a linebacker, but still play through it because he doesn't have the security in his job to sit it out, or play through it as a second string because he needs to stay in the game to stay on the team. It just made me concerned about the long term health and well-being of a fictional character.
Final Note: I noticed the map and the location of the Chevali dot. I wonder who you're going to be rooting for in the Super Bowl this weekend? :) Isn't that a funny coincidence?
For those who haven't yet read the blurb on the back of the book/website, or read the first third of the book on the web, or even seen another review by now, the story features the football playing tiger Dev and the crafty cross dressing fox Lee. Lee trips Dev in to bed, and surprise, Dev likes it! This sets up the basic premise of Lee and Dev trying to make their way as a couple in the professional sports world.
The setting is essentially a furry copy of the current modern world, the same universe and time frame as Kyell's previous novel, Waterways. He even goes so far as to map the city names he's created to various locations in the US. It's a well constructed universe, solid and fleshed out. The small school scenes feel very real to me as someone who went to a div III school in the midwest, and the later scenes still kept that feeling of authenticity even as they went into places where I don't have the experience to know any better. The setting never detracted from the story, and mostly blended into the background of the character interaction. It felt like much more of the setting was assumed, unlike the stories set in Argaea (the setting of Volle and it's sequels) where the setting was more explicity described to point out the contrasts between that world and our onw..
It is a very character driven story, and those characters are once again magnificent people who are engaging and likeable even if they do have their own set of flaws.
Dev the tiger is my favorite character in the book, the one that I want waiting for me at home. I did have some issues with his characterization though... While the issues about coming out were very thoroghly explored in Waterways and I don't expect this book to spend all it's time going over the same sort of themes, Dev's acceptance of his own sexuality feels abrupt and rushed. It just came out of the blue after this chance encounter. Dev is confused for a couple weeks, then bam, he's back to get some more from Lee. From then on, he's suddenly ok with being gay, he's just primarily worried about staying in the closet. Has Dev really made it to his junior year of college without an inkling that he liked guys? Is it something he's thought about before but Kyell didn't find the space to tell us?
There's a bit of a time gap in the story, and when it picks back up it felt like a rather abrupt switch had gotten thrown that was not properly explained or explored. There's only a brief pause before Dev is again happily handling Lee. That is a relatively minor quibble for me, as I easily got swept up in the relationship interplay between Dev and Lee, and the progression towards pro football and his efforts to survive and thrive there. Dev is sweet (though he'd probably growl if you called him that) and straightforward. Most of the time it feels like his emotions are buried and restrained, but every so often these moments pop up that just are so beautiful it made me want to cry. In particular I was touched by the scene where he meets Lee's father and deftly short circuits a rather heated argument with his genuine sincerity, as well as a moment toward the end when he asks whether he should be thinking about the future as his or as ours [his and Lee's].
Lee is a more complicated character, though it didn't necessarily feel that way to me. The drive, intelligence and willing to be a bit underhanded at need felt very familiar to me. In a lot of ways we have similar views on commitments, which made his decision to quit school to take the job resonate with me. I don't know that I could have made the same decision as Lee, but I understand exactly what forces were pulling him in each direction. Lee also faded a bit into the background in the final section of the novel. While a critical player, he was often absent, off doing a job that those of us non-sports fans may not really understand. Lee's lack of physical presence was as much a character in the final section as his presence was. It was wonderful story construction and hightened the emotional impact, but it did let his character fade and subtly change (itself an important plot point).
This is an adult novel, and there is plenty of sex. I am happy to report that OOP is in my opinion the hottest of all Kyell's novels so far. For one thing, unlike Waterways, it didn't feature underage characters I felt weird getting aroused over. It also pushed a lot more of my buttons. One thing that did bother me a little was the seeming one sidedness of the sex in the relationship. It always seemed to be the same person taking the same roles. Dev tried oral a couple times and didn't like it... There was never any discussion of any possibility of him bottoming for Lee ever. That stuck out to me, and in a way felt like it was an assumption of Dev's dominance and masculinity, playing into both masculine stereotypes (i.e. big football player couldn't take it up the butt) and furry stereotypes of foxes being submissive. It made their sex life seem rather one dimensional over the course of the novel even if the individual sex scenes were always very well done, and not exactly condusive to being read while in public.
Final thoughts: Overall I really loved this novel. I read it twice from cover to cover on the way home from Further Confusion. It is most definitely worth picking up. I was a little worried about the football, but frankly I needn't have bothered. It's mostly a story about pro athletes in general, and could have been written with baseball, hockey or whatever players instead. The football action that is there is written in an aproachable manner, but still meaty enough (I hope) for actual football fans. It's the complete package in a furry novel, and I'm betting that it's going to be the furry novel of the year.
Final [Spoilery] Thoughts: Something about the ending that bothered me in retrospect was that it felt cribbed from the Ironman movie. While reading it, everything felt right and good, but after putting the book down, for a bit I thought that the whole press-conference revelation and quick end felt rather familiar, and realized that it was almost exactly like the end of Ironman with Tony Stark poised to issue a denial, then throwing caution to the wind and bursting out his secret. It was still a blockbuster moment for me, and nearly brought me to tears both times on the plane, even if it wasn't unexpected. One other thing that bothered me was the casual drinking and driving. While it may be in character (I'm from Cincinnati, I know how those things can go) it still worried me. I lost a friend in high school to a drunk driver, and that kind of thing bothers me.
Semi-unrelated note: I have read speculation that the first pro athlete to come out while active will likely be a solid 'franchise' player or backup who is still active but approaching the end of their productive career. It wouldn't be a big name, but someone who's worked hard, hasn't made a huge impact in any kind of record books but sees an opportunity to make a name for themselves by coming out prior to retirement. I do think there is also a plausible alternative scenario with the changing environment. I could see the first out active pro athlete as someone who has been out throughout their playing career, from high school through college and into the pros. That would be someone who was a natural and truly gifted athlete, a star who's talent ensures they cannot be overlooked by recruiters, but who stepped out of the closet such a long time ago that there would be no 'coming out' press because that happened so long ago that it faded into a non-issue.
Tangentially related note: On CNN headlines the other day there was a story about the progressive brain damage players in the NFL suffer due to repeated concussions and playing through concussions. That made me really worry about Dev, as he's the kind of player (at least right now) who would be very likely to suffer a concussion as a linebacker, but still play through it because he doesn't have the security in his job to sit it out, or play through it as a second string because he needs to stay in the game to stay on the team. It just made me concerned about the long term health and well-being of a fictional character.
Final Note: I noticed the map and the location of the Chevali dot. I wonder who you're going to be rooting for in the Super Bowl this weekend? :) Isn't that a funny coincidence?
Out of Position Review
This is a review is cross posted (after slight editing) from my own LJ. It contains a fair number of spoilers, so it'll be behind a nice big cut.
For those who haven't yet read the blurb on the back of the book/website, or read the first third of the book on the web, or even seen another review by now, the story features the football playing tiger Dev and the crafty cross dressing fox Lee. Lee trips Dev in to bed, and surprise, Dev likes it! This sets up the basic premise of Lee and Dev trying to make their way as a couple in the professional sports world.
The setting is essentially a furry copy of the current modern world, the same universe and time frame as Kyell's previous novel, Waterways. He even goes so far as to map the city names he's created to various locations in the US. It's a well constructed universe, solid and fleshed out. The small school scenes feel very real to me as someone who went to a div III school in the midwest, and the later scenes still kept that feeling of authenticity even as they went into places where I don't have the experience to know any better. The setting never detracted from the story, and mostly blended into the background of the character interaction. It felt like much more of the setting was assumed, unlike the stories set in Argaea (the setting of Volle and it's sequels) where the setting was more explicity described to point out the contrasts between that world and our onw..
It is a very character driven story, and those characters are once again magnificent people who are engaging and likeable even if they do have their own set of flaws.
Dev the tiger is my favorite character in the book, the one that I want waiting for me at home. I did have some issues with his characterization though... While the issues about coming out were very thoroghly explored in Waterways and I don't expect this book to spend all it's time going over the same sort of themes, Dev's acceptance of his own sexuality feels abrupt and rushed. It just came out of the blue after this chance encounter. Dev is confused for a couple weeks, then bam, he's back to get some more from Lee. From then on, he's suddenly ok with being gay, he's just primarily worried about staying in the closet. Has Dev really made it to his junior year of college without an inkling that he liked guys? Is it something he's thought about before but Kyell didn't find the space to tell us?
There's a bit of a time gap in the story, and when it picks back up it felt like a rather abrupt switch had gotten thrown that was not properly explained or explored. There's only a brief pause before Dev is again happily handling Lee. That is a relatively minor quibble for me, as I easily got swept up in the relationship interplay between Dev and Lee, and the progression towards pro football and his efforts to survive and thrive there. Dev is sweet (though he'd probably growl if you called him that) and straightforward. Most of the time it feels like his emotions are buried and restrained, but every so often these moments pop up that just are so beautiful it made me want to cry. In particular I was touched by the scene where he meets Lee's father and deftly short circuits a rather heated argument with his genuine sincerity, as well as a moment toward the end when he asks whether he should be thinking about the future as his or as ours [his and Lee's].
Lee is a more complicated character, though it didn't necessarily feel that way to me. The drive, intelligence and willing to be a bit underhanded at need felt very familiar to me. In a lot of ways we have similar views on commitments, which made his decision to quit school to take the job resonate with me. I don't know that I could have made the same decision as Lee, but I understand exactly what forces were pulling him in each direction. Lee also faded a bit into the background in the final section of the novel. While a critical player, he was often absent, off doing a job that those of us non-sports fans may not really understand. Lee's lack of physical presence was as much a character in the final section as his presence was. It was wonderful story construction and hightened the emotional impact, but it did let his character fade and subtly change (itself an important plot point).
This is an adult novel, and there is plenty of sex. I am happy to report that OOP is in my opinion the hottest of all Kyell's novels so far. For one thing, unlike Waterways, it didn't feature underage characters I felt weird getting aroused over. It also pushed a lot more of my buttons. One thing that did bother me a little was the seeming one sidedness of the sex in the relationship. It always seemed to be the same person taking the same roles. Dev tried oral a couple times and didn't like it... There was never any discussion of any possibility of him bottoming for Lee ever. That stuck out to me, and in a way felt like it was an assumption of Dev's dominance and masculinity, playing into both masculine stereotypes (i.e. big football player couldn't take it up the butt) and furry stereotypes of foxes being submissive. It made their sex life seem rather one dimensional over the course of the novel even if the individual sex scenes were always very well done, and not exactly condusive to being read while in public.
Final thoughts: Overall I really loved this novel. I read it twice from cover to cover on the way home from Further Confusion. It is most definitely worth picking up. I was a little worried about the football, but frankly I needn't have bothered. It's mostly a story about pro athletes in general, and could have been written with baseball, hockey or whatever players instead. The football action that is there is written in an aproachable manner, but still meaty enough (I hope) for actual football fans. It's the complete package in a furry novel, and I'm betting that it's going to be the furry novel of the year.
Final [Spoilery] Thoughts: Something about the ending that bothered me in retrospect was that it felt cribbed from the Ironman movie. While reading it, everything felt right and good, but after putting the book down, for a bit I thought that the whole press-conference revelation and quick end felt rather familiar, and realized that it was almost exactly like the end of Ironman with Tony Stark poised to issue a denial, then throwing caution to the wind and bursting out his secret. It was still a blockbuster moment for me, and nearly brought me to tears both times on the plane, even if it wasn't unexpected. One other thing that bothered me was the casual drinking and driving. While it may be in character (I'm from Cincinnati, I know how those things can go) it still worried me. I lost a friend in high school to a drunk driver, and that kind of thing bothers me.
Semi-unrelated note: I have read speculation that the first pro athlete to come out while active will likely be a solid 'franchise' player or backup who is still active but approaching the end of their productive career. It wouldn't be a big name, but someone who's worked hard, hasn't made a huge impact in any kind of record books but sees an opportunity to make a name for themselves by coming out prior to retirement. I do think there is also a plausible alternative scenario with the changing environment. I could see the first out active pro athlete as someone who has been out throughout their playing career, from high school through college and into the pros. That would be someone who was a natural and truly gifted athlete, a star who's talent ensures they cannot be overlooked by recruiters, but who stepped out of the closet such a long time ago that there would be no 'coming out' press because that happened so long ago that it faded into a non-issue.
Tangentially related note: On CNN headlines the other day there was a story about the progressive brain damage players in the NFL suffer due to repeated concussions and playing through concussions. That made me really worry about Dev, as he's the kind of player (at least right now) who would be very likely to suffer a concussion as a linebacker, but still play through it because he doesn't have the security in his job to sit it out, or play through it as a second string because he needs to stay in the game to stay on the team. It just made me concerned about the long term health and well-being of a fictional character.
Final Note: I noticed the map and the location of the Chevali dot. I wonder who you're going to be rooting for in the Super Bowl this weekend? :) Isn't that a funny coincidence?
For those who haven't yet read the blurb on the back of the book/website, or read the first third of the book on the web, or even seen another review by now, the story features the football playing tiger Dev and the crafty cross dressing fox Lee. Lee trips Dev in to bed, and surprise, Dev likes it! This sets up the basic premise of Lee and Dev trying to make their way as a couple in the professional sports world.
The setting is essentially a furry copy of the current modern world, the same universe and time frame as Kyell's previous novel, Waterways. He even goes so far as to map the city names he's created to various locations in the US. It's a well constructed universe, solid and fleshed out. The small school scenes feel very real to me as someone who went to a div III school in the midwest, and the later scenes still kept that feeling of authenticity even as they went into places where I don't have the experience to know any better. The setting never detracted from the story, and mostly blended into the background of the character interaction. It felt like much more of the setting was assumed, unlike the stories set in Argaea (the setting of Volle and it's sequels) where the setting was more explicity described to point out the contrasts between that world and our onw..
It is a very character driven story, and those characters are once again magnificent people who are engaging and likeable even if they do have their own set of flaws.
Dev the tiger is my favorite character in the book, the one that I want waiting for me at home. I did have some issues with his characterization though... While the issues about coming out were very thoroghly explored in Waterways and I don't expect this book to spend all it's time going over the same sort of themes, Dev's acceptance of his own sexuality feels abrupt and rushed. It just came out of the blue after this chance encounter. Dev is confused for a couple weeks, then bam, he's back to get some more from Lee. From then on, he's suddenly ok with being gay, he's just primarily worried about staying in the closet. Has Dev really made it to his junior year of college without an inkling that he liked guys? Is it something he's thought about before but Kyell didn't find the space to tell us?
There's a bit of a time gap in the story, and when it picks back up it felt like a rather abrupt switch had gotten thrown that was not properly explained or explored. There's only a brief pause before Dev is again happily handling Lee. That is a relatively minor quibble for me, as I easily got swept up in the relationship interplay between Dev and Lee, and the progression towards pro football and his efforts to survive and thrive there. Dev is sweet (though he'd probably growl if you called him that) and straightforward. Most of the time it feels like his emotions are buried and restrained, but every so often these moments pop up that just are so beautiful it made me want to cry. In particular I was touched by the scene where he meets Lee's father and deftly short circuits a rather heated argument with his genuine sincerity, as well as a moment toward the end when he asks whether he should be thinking about the future as his or as ours [his and Lee's].
Lee is a more complicated character, though it didn't necessarily feel that way to me. The drive, intelligence and willing to be a bit underhanded at need felt very familiar to me. In a lot of ways we have similar views on commitments, which made his decision to quit school to take the job resonate with me. I don't know that I could have made the same decision as Lee, but I understand exactly what forces were pulling him in each direction. Lee also faded a bit into the background in the final section of the novel. While a critical player, he was often absent, off doing a job that those of us non-sports fans may not really understand. Lee's lack of physical presence was as much a character in the final section as his presence was. It was wonderful story construction and hightened the emotional impact, but it did let his character fade and subtly change (itself an important plot point).
This is an adult novel, and there is plenty of sex. I am happy to report that OOP is in my opinion the hottest of all Kyell's novels so far. For one thing, unlike Waterways, it didn't feature underage characters I felt weird getting aroused over. It also pushed a lot more of my buttons. One thing that did bother me a little was the seeming one sidedness of the sex in the relationship. It always seemed to be the same person taking the same roles. Dev tried oral a couple times and didn't like it... There was never any discussion of any possibility of him bottoming for Lee ever. That stuck out to me, and in a way felt like it was an assumption of Dev's dominance and masculinity, playing into both masculine stereotypes (i.e. big football player couldn't take it up the butt) and furry stereotypes of foxes being submissive. It made their sex life seem rather one dimensional over the course of the novel even if the individual sex scenes were always very well done, and not exactly condusive to being read while in public.
Final thoughts: Overall I really loved this novel. I read it twice from cover to cover on the way home from Further Confusion. It is most definitely worth picking up. I was a little worried about the football, but frankly I needn't have bothered. It's mostly a story about pro athletes in general, and could have been written with baseball, hockey or whatever players instead. The football action that is there is written in an aproachable manner, but still meaty enough (I hope) for actual football fans. It's the complete package in a furry novel, and I'm betting that it's going to be the furry novel of the year.
Final [Spoilery] Thoughts: Something about the ending that bothered me in retrospect was that it felt cribbed from the Ironman movie. While reading it, everything felt right and good, but after putting the book down, for a bit I thought that the whole press-conference revelation and quick end felt rather familiar, and realized that it was almost exactly like the end of Ironman with Tony Stark poised to issue a denial, then throwing caution to the wind and bursting out his secret. It was still a blockbuster moment for me, and nearly brought me to tears both times on the plane, even if it wasn't unexpected. One other thing that bothered me was the casual drinking and driving. While it may be in character (I'm from Cincinnati, I know how those things can go) it still worried me. I lost a friend in high school to a drunk driver, and that kind of thing bothers me.
Semi-unrelated note: I have read speculation that the first pro athlete to come out while active will likely be a solid 'franchise' player or backup who is still active but approaching the end of their productive career. It wouldn't be a big name, but someone who's worked hard, hasn't made a huge impact in any kind of record books but sees an opportunity to make a name for themselves by coming out prior to retirement. I do think there is also a plausible alternative scenario with the changing environment. I could see the first out active pro athlete as someone who has been out throughout their playing career, from high school through college and into the pros. That would be someone who was a natural and truly gifted athlete, a star who's talent ensures they cannot be overlooked by recruiters, but who stepped out of the closet such a long time ago that there would be no 'coming out' press because that happened so long ago that it faded into a non-issue.
Tangentially related note: On CNN headlines the other day there was a story about the progressive brain damage players in the NFL suffer due to repeated concussions and playing through concussions. That made me really worry about Dev, as he's the kind of player (at least right now) who would be very likely to suffer a concussion as a linebacker, but still play through it because he doesn't have the security in his job to sit it out, or play through it as a second string because he needs to stay in the game to stay on the team. It just made me concerned about the long term health and well-being of a fictional character.
Final Note: I noticed the map and the location of the Chevali dot. I wonder who you're going to be rooting for in the Super Bowl this weekend? :) Isn't that a funny coincidence?
Out of Position
I've reviewed many of Kyell Gold's books in the past. I almost wasn't going to do one for Out of Position, out of the notion that I should give someone else a shot, first, but given how popular the book seems to have been right at its release, I'm going to guess that reviews will be popping up everywhere soon enough, and I have no reason not to add my voice to the pile.
As a brief disclaimer, first: it's probably no big secret, especially to Kyell's fans, that he and I are very close friends, but as a fellow writer, I try to keep my bias out of my literary opinions as much as I can. Also, I did do some work helping to edit Out of Position, as well, but I'll come back to that point later.
Now, on to the review proper:
Out of Position is fairly unique for one of Gold's novels in that it's the first book that he has written that really has a contemporary adult theme to it; Waterways (set in the same fictional universe) handles the young adult angle, but Out of Position is more about grown-ups and the problems that a relationship can have in the real, grown-up world.
The story concerns a tiger named Devlin Miski, a tiger who plays football for Forester University, and his fateful run-in with a tricky, sneaky (and very sexy) fox, Wiley "Lee" Farrel. Initially seduced by Lee in all-too-convincing drag, Dev ends up having his first sexual encounter with another male, and is forced to reevaluate first his sexuality, and then the other values in his life.
From there, the plot follows both Dev and Lee (through switching perspectives) over the course of their growing relationship. What starts with a one-night-stand (and revenge plot) turns into a very serious relationship that has more than a fair share of bumps for both of our protagonists. What really makes the book click is the expert way that real-life relationship problems are handled: they have stupid fights where both of them are in the wrong; pressure from family and friends force folks to make tough decisions; school and sports and a whole bunch of other things keep trying to get in the way.
If Waterways is the story of figuring out who you are and how to go out and face the world, then Out of Position is the story about being out there in the world and being forced to deal with all of its pressures while still staying true to yourself and the people you love--and the very tricky art of finding the balance between those things.
Football plays a very big part in the book, but as Gold himself states in the introduction, it's not a story about football. Since (again, as Gold himself points out) most gay furry romance readers probably aren't huge football fans, it's worth pointing out that the story is, at its core, a gay furry romance novel and not a piece of sports fiction. Early in the book, there's even a nice, succinct, very helpful aside that explains football in a brief overview that only lasts two pages and which should give even the most clueless reader enough knowledge of the sport to understand the references in the rest of the book. So, fret not, gentle readers: don't let the big, scary football stuff scare you off. (Besides, look at that cover, and tell me that Dev doesn't look delicious in that uniform.)
That's another thing that definitely warrants mentioning: this is a very, very sexy book. The two main characters are very confused and conflicted, and this leads to quite a lot of pent-up emotions and outbursts of passion, and Mr. Gold has outdone himself, more than once, in putting together some truly arousing sex scenes this time around. Whereas Waterways more just touched the surface of youthful sexuality, Out of Position gets good and explicit quite a number of times, and the quality of those scenes is something that no connoisseur of furry erotica need worry about.
As sexy as the book is, though, the emotional heart of it is even stronger. During the last quarter of the book, I got choked up repeatedly, even when reading sections of it in public. It's a beautiful story--unquestionably Gold's best--and I daren't spoil any more details of it here. In the aforementioned process of helping to edit the book, I read the bulk of it no fewer than three or four times, and never got sick of it or felt like any of it lost its impact.
The end result is a spectacular read that paints some terrific characters, gives a top-notch romantic story, and includes some really great written erotica on top like the cherry on the proverbial sundae (and that's not even including the gorgeous interior illustrations by Blotch, either!). Fans of Kyell Gold's work cannot go wrong by checking this book out. Gay furry romance fans who don't think that the written part of our fandom is worth taking a look at ought to take a look at this to see how it's done.
Out of Position
I've reviewed many of Kyell Gold's books in the past. I almost wasn't going to do one for Out of Position, out of the notion that I should give someone else a shot, first, but given how popular the book seems to have been right at its release, I'm going to guess that reviews will be popping up everywhere soon enough, and I have no reason not to add my voice to the pile.
As a brief disclaimer, first: it's probably no big secret, especially to Kyell's fans, that he and I are very close friends, but as a fellow writer, I try to keep my bias out of my literary opinions as much as I can. Also, I did do some work helping to edit Out of Position, as well, but I'll come back to that point later.
Now, on to the review proper:
Out of Position is fairly unique for one of Gold's novels in that it's the first book that he has written that really has a contemporary adult theme to it; Waterways (set in the same fictional universe) handles the young adult angle, but Out of Position is more about grown-ups and the problems that a relationship can have in the real, grown-up world.
The story concerns a tiger named Devlin Miski, a tiger who plays football for Forester University, and his fateful run-in with a tricky, sneaky (and very sexy) fox, Wiley "Lee" Farrel. Initially seduced by Lee in all-too-convincing drag, Dev ends up having his first sexual encounter with another male, and is forced to reevaluate first his sexuality, and then the other values in his life.
From there, the plot follows both Dev and Lee (through switching perspectives) over the course of their growing relationship. What starts with a one-night-stand (and revenge plot) turns into a very serious relationship that has more than a fair share of bumps for both of our protagonists. What really makes the book click is the expert way that real-life relationship problems are handled: they have stupid fights where both of them are in the wrong; pressure from family and friends force folks to make tough decisions; school and sports and a whole bunch of other things keep trying to get in the way.
If Waterways is the story of figuring out who you are and how to go out and face the world, then Out of Position is the story about being out there in the world and being forced to deal with all of its pressures while still staying true to yourself and the people you love--and the very tricky art of finding the balance between those things.
Football plays a very big part in the book, but as Gold himself states in the introduction, it's not a story about football. Since (again, as Gold himself points out) most gay furry romance readers probably aren't huge football fans, it's worth pointing out that the story is, at its core, a gay furry romance novel and not a piece of sports fiction. Early in the book, there's even a nice, succinct, very helpful aside that explains football in a brief overview that only lasts two pages and which should give even the most clueless reader enough knowledge of the sport to understand the references in the rest of the book. So, fret not, gentle readers: don't let the big, scary football stuff scare you off. (Besides, look at that cover, and tell me that Dev doesn't look delicious in that uniform.)
That's another thing that definitely warrants mentioning: this is a very, very sexy book. The two main characters are very confused and conflicted, and this leads to quite a lot of pent-up emotions and outbursts of passion, and Mr. Gold has outdone himself, more than once, in putting together some truly arousing sex scenes this time around. Whereas Waterways more just touched the surface of youthful sexuality, Out of Position gets good and explicit quite a number of times, and the quality of those scenes is something that no connoisseur of furry erotica need worry about.
As sexy as the book is, though, the emotional heart of it is even stronger. During the last quarter of the book, I got choked up repeatedly, even when reading sections of it in public. It's a beautiful story--unquestionably Gold's best--and I daren't spoil any more details of it here. In the aforementioned process of helping to edit the book, I read the bulk of it no fewer than three or four times, and never got sick of it or felt like any of it lost its impact.
The end result is a spectacular read that paints some terrific characters, gives a top-notch romantic story, and includes some really great written erotica on top like the cherry on the proverbial sundae (and that's not even including the gorgeous interior illustrations by Blotch, either!). Fans of Kyell Gold's work cannot go wrong by checking this book out. Gay furry romance fans who don't think that the written part of our fandom is worth taking a look at ought to take a look at this to see how it's done.
Episode 84--New Fur Survey, CSI and FC - Woyro talks about a new Furry Survey, news about the furry CSI episode and a shout out to Further Confusion.
Woyro talks about a new Furry Survey, news about the furry CSI episode and a shout out to Further Confusion.
Episode 84--New Fur Survey, CSI and FC - Woyro talks about a new Furry Survey, news about the furry CSI episode and a shout out to Further Confusion.
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 83---Passports and Battle Royale - this week Woyro talks about renewing his Passport, making flight plans for a couple cons and reviews BATTLE ROYALE & BATTLE ROYALE 2.
this week Woyro talks about renewing his Passport, making flight plans for a couple cons and reviews BATTLE ROYALE & BATTLE ROYALE 2.
Episode 83---Passports and Battle Royale - this week Woyro talks about renewing his Passport, making flight plans for a couple cons and reviews BATTLE ROYALE & BATTLE ROYALE 2.
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 82---Spaghetti western reviews - Woyro does a quick update and talks about some spaghetti westerns.
Woyro does a quick update and talks about some spaghetti westerns.
Episode 82---Spaghetti western reviews - Woyro does a quick update and talks about some spaghetti westerns.
Categories: Podcasts
Analogues - 001 - Jan 07, 2009
Pilot episode of Analogues, recorded January 7, 2009."Stick Figures" © AnimusicAll other content ©2009 Tanuke Media Analogues - 001 - Jan 07, 2009
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 81--New Year & Orlando trip - Woyro talks about his long weekend in Orlando and upcomming conventions.
Woyro talks about his long weekend in Orlando and upcomming conventions.
Episode 81--New Year & Orlando trip - Woyro talks about his long weekend in Orlando and upcomming conventions.
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 80--2009 Cons & Lovecraft - Woyro catches up with his convention plans for 2009 and rants about some great HP Lovecraft movies.
Woyro catches up with his convention plans for 2009 and rants about some great HP Lovecraft movies.
Episode 80--2009 Cons & Lovecraft - Woyro catches up with his convention plans for 2009 and rants about some great HP Lovecraft movies.
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 79---Furry Sociology - Woyro talks about a furry survey and plays a song by TV's Kyle. some slightly naughty words will be spoken.
Woyro talks about a furry survey and plays a song by TV's Kyle. some slightly naughty words will be spoken.
Episode 79---Furry Sociology - Woyro talks about a furry survey and plays a song by TV's Kyle. some slightly naughty words will be spoken.
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 78 Repost---Catching Up - Reposted!!! Woyro talks about what he's been doing for the past few weeks.
Reposted!!! Woyro talks about what he's been doing for the past few weeks.
Episode 78 Repost---Catching Up - Reposted!!! Woyro talks about what he's been doing for the past few weeks.
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 78---Quick Update! - Woyro rambles on for a few minutes about whats been keeping him so darn busy lately!
Woyro rambles on for a few minutes about whats been keeping him so darn busy lately!
Episode 78---Quick Update! - Woyro rambles on for a few minutes about whats been keeping him so darn busy lately!
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 77--New things at the Warren! - there are changes afoot for Woyro's Warren. Woyro also talks about a few people he met because of the show.
there are changes afoot for Woyro's Warren. Woyro also talks about a few people he met because of the show.
Episode 77--New things at the Warren! - there are changes afoot for Woyro's Warren. Woyro also talks about a few people he met because of the show.
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 76---Vacation to Mephit Furmeet - Woyro talks about his 11 day vacation and trip to Mephit Furmeet.
Woyro talks about his 11 day vacation and trip to Mephit Furmeet.
Episode 76---Vacation to Mephit Furmeet - Woyro talks about his 11 day vacation and trip to Mephit Furmeet.
Categories: Podcasts
Episode 75---On Vacation - Woyro talks about furry news, Bigfoot and other crazy animal stories as he prepares for Mephit Furmeet.
Woyro talks about furry news, Bigfoot and other crazy animal stories as he prepares for Mephit Furmeet.
Episode 75---On Vacation - Woyro talks about furry news, Bigfoot and other crazy animal stories as he prepares for Mephit Furmeet.
Categories: Podcasts
Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures
Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures
By Walter Moers
Translated from the German by John Brownjohn
2006 The Overlook Press
ISBN: 1-58567-725-6
Since Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures by Walter Moers is a fantasy epic, Rumo, our protagonist, is of course an orphan. In the first book of the novel, he is taken from his home by monsters and imprisoned in a tower, learns to be a warrior, and eventually escapes. In the second book, now grown, he sets out to rescue his love who was kidnapped by forces of evil. This is quite possibly the oldest fantasy plot there is—it certainly seems the most common, but this is not always a bad thing.
In his 1973 interview with documentarian Richard Schickel, Alfred Hitchcock argued that the plots of all his films were at their heart entirely predictable and formulaic—and that the reason the films themselves aren’t repetitive and dull is entirely due to characterization. It is the individuals in these films--their motivations, emotions, impulses and thoughts that make a work unique and indeed alive. Hitchcock so believed in this concept that he coined the term MacGuffin, an item or plot device that is the motivation for the characters in the film, but is of little or no importance to the audience when compared to the actions of the characters themselves.
Though the tools used to create rich and layered characters in film differ from the techniques used in the novel, the central importance of characterization in a work does not, for novels invariably tell the same sorts of tales time and again, and in this Rumo is no different. Fortunately, for all of us, Walter Moers populates Rumo with an endless variety of bizarre and interesting people, who though caught in webs of larger events, pursue their own agendas under the weight of their own emotions, neuroses, and histories. It is the richness of the world and the characters that Moers peoples it with that make Rumo rise above the great mass of fantasy novels.
Moers was a long time comic and graphic novel writer in and illustrator in Germany before he began writing novels set in the fictional continent of Zamonia. He is obviously enjoys a high degree of familiarity with the conventions of the fantasy genre, and he grabs the reader right from the start by turning one such fantasy convention slightly on its side. Like so many fantasy heroes in recent years, Rumo is an orphan (see Harry Potter, Sabriel, The Golden Compass, to name but a few). Authors do this of course so that their young protagonists can act like adults. They are free to make their own choices. One also gets the feeling that authors sometimes make their heroes orphans to do gain a hair more of the reader’s sympathy as well!
Rumo is different from most fantast orphans because his orphan-hood is not tragic, but rather a part of who his people are. Rumo is a Wolperting, half dog-half deer, and looks like a large dog with small horns on his head. Stories of the species are native to Moers’ Germany in the way that tales of jackalopes are told in the Southwestern United States. Wolpertings abandon all their children in forests soon after they are born, and the reason they do this is extraordinary. Some Wolpertings stay wild animals their whole lives, living as dumb beasts in the forest. Others, such as Rumo, make a conscious choice to become people. They decide to walk upright, talk, and eventually make their way to the city of Wolperting. In short sentience is not automatic, but rather a choice. Because of the recognition of this choice, because it had to be done se he could become a Wolperting, Rumo never feels tortured over his lost parents, and this is a rather refreshing change for a book in the fantasy genre. It is simply bad luck that no sooner than Rumo chooses to be a person he is kidnapped by cannibals, taken to their floating island, and the adventure begins in earnest.
It is Rumo’s journey to becoming a person that is the dominant thread of the first book of the novel. In this, he is guided by Volzotan Smyke, the shark-grub, the first of the many rather bizarre characters Rumo encounters over the course of his journeys. When introducing a new character Moers does something that could be very distracting—he pauses Rumo’s story and tells each new character’s story up to the point they meet Rumo—how they got there and perhaps where they want to go. He even sets out a note in the margins introducing the story each time one is told. These little asides could be detrimental to the overall novel, breaking the flow of the story. However, each character’s story is paid such beautiful and detailed attention that it becomes more than an aside. Even the minor characters have richly detailed and complicated lives and their tales provide essential information in many cases, as these characters will very often re-enter Rumo’s story later on, and their motivations in the present become clear in the light of their past histories. It’s a rather unconventional technique, but it works, in large part because Moers creates such a strong main plot arc that these diversions enrich rather than pull one away from the overall story.
Part of the joy of Rumo’s discovering what it means to be a person is that he becomes a Wolperting person, and not a human person. K.M. Hirosaki, among others, has pointed out that often in furry literature species is simply a “cosmetic veneer” playing little role in advancing either plot or characterization. Moers, though not a furry (as far as I know) makes no such mistake. Being a Wolperting is a unique experience, as is being a shark-grub, a clockwork warrior, or an undead ice yeti. The world of Wolpertings is one filled with marks of personhood—speech, literature, studies, warfare, love, even bureaucracy, but in ways that make each of these things distinctly Wolperting. Moers very effectively is able to convey how Wolpertings use their senses in ways that are radically different from humans or the other people of the continent of Zamonia. My favorite device is that young male Wolpertings follow a “silver thread” of scent when they close their eyes that leads them over hundreds of miles to their future mate.
Walter Moers writing also has a highly humorous style; comparable at times to Lewis Carroll—there are innumerable moments while reading where one is overcome by laughter. This is counterpointed by moments of cruelty and violence however, particularly in book two, where Rumo journeys deep into the underworld and the violence more than anything (but also the vocabulary level and length at 687 pages) make this not a book for children. However, its playfulness and grand adventure style makes it strongly reminiscent of those books we enjoyed as children. The translation of the book from its original German by John Brownjohn is also a strong point. I have not read the original, but the language of the English version is artful, idiomatic, and at no time feels like a translation.
Ultimately, Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures is a very good book. It falls short of being a ‘great’ book in that there are no profound ideas explored, apart from perhaps the already aforementioned choosing to be a person as a child, and it doesn’t make one think in ways that the truly great books do. That said it more than accomplishes what it sets out to do, providing a rollicking and diverting grand adventure. It is a joyful book, a celebration of being alive in a bizarre world. It was difficult to put down, and passes that perhaps greatest test of any book for me—when I finished it I had that feeling of “So now what do I do with my life?”
-Skip Ruddertail
By Walter Moers
Translated from the German by John Brownjohn
2006 The Overlook Press
ISBN: 1-58567-725-6
Since Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures by Walter Moers is a fantasy epic, Rumo, our protagonist, is of course an orphan. In the first book of the novel, he is taken from his home by monsters and imprisoned in a tower, learns to be a warrior, and eventually escapes. In the second book, now grown, he sets out to rescue his love who was kidnapped by forces of evil. This is quite possibly the oldest fantasy plot there is—it certainly seems the most common, but this is not always a bad thing.
In his 1973 interview with documentarian Richard Schickel, Alfred Hitchcock argued that the plots of all his films were at their heart entirely predictable and formulaic—and that the reason the films themselves aren’t repetitive and dull is entirely due to characterization. It is the individuals in these films--their motivations, emotions, impulses and thoughts that make a work unique and indeed alive. Hitchcock so believed in this concept that he coined the term MacGuffin, an item or plot device that is the motivation for the characters in the film, but is of little or no importance to the audience when compared to the actions of the characters themselves.
Though the tools used to create rich and layered characters in film differ from the techniques used in the novel, the central importance of characterization in a work does not, for novels invariably tell the same sorts of tales time and again, and in this Rumo is no different. Fortunately, for all of us, Walter Moers populates Rumo with an endless variety of bizarre and interesting people, who though caught in webs of larger events, pursue their own agendas under the weight of their own emotions, neuroses, and histories. It is the richness of the world and the characters that Moers peoples it with that make Rumo rise above the great mass of fantasy novels.
Moers was a long time comic and graphic novel writer in and illustrator in Germany before he began writing novels set in the fictional continent of Zamonia. He is obviously enjoys a high degree of familiarity with the conventions of the fantasy genre, and he grabs the reader right from the start by turning one such fantasy convention slightly on its side. Like so many fantasy heroes in recent years, Rumo is an orphan (see Harry Potter, Sabriel, The Golden Compass, to name but a few). Authors do this of course so that their young protagonists can act like adults. They are free to make their own choices. One also gets the feeling that authors sometimes make their heroes orphans to do gain a hair more of the reader’s sympathy as well!
Rumo is different from most fantast orphans because his orphan-hood is not tragic, but rather a part of who his people are. Rumo is a Wolperting, half dog-half deer, and looks like a large dog with small horns on his head. Stories of the species are native to Moers’ Germany in the way that tales of jackalopes are told in the Southwestern United States. Wolpertings abandon all their children in forests soon after they are born, and the reason they do this is extraordinary. Some Wolpertings stay wild animals their whole lives, living as dumb beasts in the forest. Others, such as Rumo, make a conscious choice to become people. They decide to walk upright, talk, and eventually make their way to the city of Wolperting. In short sentience is not automatic, but rather a choice. Because of the recognition of this choice, because it had to be done se he could become a Wolperting, Rumo never feels tortured over his lost parents, and this is a rather refreshing change for a book in the fantasy genre. It is simply bad luck that no sooner than Rumo chooses to be a person he is kidnapped by cannibals, taken to their floating island, and the adventure begins in earnest.
It is Rumo’s journey to becoming a person that is the dominant thread of the first book of the novel. In this, he is guided by Volzotan Smyke, the shark-grub, the first of the many rather bizarre characters Rumo encounters over the course of his journeys. When introducing a new character Moers does something that could be very distracting—he pauses Rumo’s story and tells each new character’s story up to the point they meet Rumo—how they got there and perhaps where they want to go. He even sets out a note in the margins introducing the story each time one is told. These little asides could be detrimental to the overall novel, breaking the flow of the story. However, each character’s story is paid such beautiful and detailed attention that it becomes more than an aside. Even the minor characters have richly detailed and complicated lives and their tales provide essential information in many cases, as these characters will very often re-enter Rumo’s story later on, and their motivations in the present become clear in the light of their past histories. It’s a rather unconventional technique, but it works, in large part because Moers creates such a strong main plot arc that these diversions enrich rather than pull one away from the overall story.
Part of the joy of Rumo’s discovering what it means to be a person is that he becomes a Wolperting person, and not a human person. K.M. Hirosaki, among others, has pointed out that often in furry literature species is simply a “cosmetic veneer” playing little role in advancing either plot or characterization. Moers, though not a furry (as far as I know) makes no such mistake. Being a Wolperting is a unique experience, as is being a shark-grub, a clockwork warrior, or an undead ice yeti. The world of Wolpertings is one filled with marks of personhood—speech, literature, studies, warfare, love, even bureaucracy, but in ways that make each of these things distinctly Wolperting. Moers very effectively is able to convey how Wolpertings use their senses in ways that are radically different from humans or the other people of the continent of Zamonia. My favorite device is that young male Wolpertings follow a “silver thread” of scent when they close their eyes that leads them over hundreds of miles to their future mate.
Walter Moers writing also has a highly humorous style; comparable at times to Lewis Carroll—there are innumerable moments while reading where one is overcome by laughter. This is counterpointed by moments of cruelty and violence however, particularly in book two, where Rumo journeys deep into the underworld and the violence more than anything (but also the vocabulary level and length at 687 pages) make this not a book for children. However, its playfulness and grand adventure style makes it strongly reminiscent of those books we enjoyed as children. The translation of the book from its original German by John Brownjohn is also a strong point. I have not read the original, but the language of the English version is artful, idiomatic, and at no time feels like a translation.
Ultimately, Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures is a very good book. It falls short of being a ‘great’ book in that there are no profound ideas explored, apart from perhaps the already aforementioned choosing to be a person as a child, and it doesn’t make one think in ways that the truly great books do. That said it more than accomplishes what it sets out to do, providing a rollicking and diverting grand adventure. It is a joyful book, a celebration of being alive in a bizarre world. It was difficult to put down, and passes that perhaps greatest test of any book for me—when I finished it I had that feeling of “So now what do I do with my life?”
-Skip Ruddertail
Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures
Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures
By Walter Moers
Translated from the German by John Brownjohn
2006 The Overlook Press
ISBN: 1-58567-725-6
Since Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures by Walter Moers is a fantasy epic, Rumo, our protagonist, is of course an orphan. In the first book of the novel, he is taken from his home by monsters and imprisoned in a tower, learns to be a warrior, and eventually escapes. In the second book, now grown, he sets out to rescue his love who was kidnapped by forces of evil. This is quite possibly the oldest fantasy plot there is—it certainly seems the most common, but this is not always a bad thing.
In his 1973 interview with documentarian Richard Schickel, Alfred Hitchcock argued that the plots of all his films were at their heart entirely predictable and formulaic—and that the reason the films themselves aren’t repetitive and dull is entirely due to characterization. It is the individuals in these films--their motivations, emotions, impulses and thoughts that make a work unique and indeed alive. Hitchcock so believed in this concept that he coined the term MacGuffin, an item or plot device that is the motivation for the characters in the film, but is of little or no importance to the audience when compared to the actions of the characters themselves.
Though the tools used to create rich and layered characters in film differ from the techniques used in the novel, the central importance of characterization in a work does not, for novels invariably tell the same sorts of tales time and again, and in this Rumo is no different. Fortunately, for all of us, Walter Moers populates Rumo with an endless variety of bizarre and interesting people, who though caught in webs of larger events, pursue their own agendas under the weight of their own emotions, neuroses, and histories. It is the richness of the world and the characters that Moers peoples it with that make Rumo rise above the great mass of fantasy novels.
Moers was a long time comic and graphic novel writer in and illustrator in Germany before he began writing novels set in the fictional continent of Zamonia. He is obviously enjoys a high degree of familiarity with the conventions of the fantasy genre, and he grabs the reader right from the start by turning one such fantasy convention slightly on its side. Like so many fantasy heroes in recent years, Rumo is an orphan (see Harry Potter, Sabriel, The Golden Compass, to name but a few). Authors do this of course so that their young protagonists can act like adults. They are free to make their own choices. One also gets the feeling that authors sometimes make their heroes orphans to do gain a hair more of the reader’s sympathy as well!
Rumo is different from most fantast orphans because his orphan-hood is not tragic, but rather a part of who his people are. Rumo is a Wolperting, half dog-half deer, and looks like a large dog with small horns on his head. Stories of the species are native to Moers’ Germany in the way that tales of jackalopes are told in the Southwestern United States. Wolpertings abandon all their children in forests soon after they are born, and the reason they do this is extraordinary. Some Wolpertings stay wild animals their whole lives, living as dumb beasts in the forest. Others, such as Rumo, make a conscious choice to become people. They decide to walk upright, talk, and eventually make their way to the city of Wolperting. In short sentience is not automatic, but rather a choice. Because of the recognition of this choice, because it had to be done se he could become a Wolperting, Rumo never feels tortured over his lost parents, and this is a rather refreshing change for a book in the fantasy genre. It is simply bad luck that no sooner than Rumo chooses to be a person he is kidnapped by cannibals, taken to their floating island, and the adventure begins in earnest.
It is Rumo’s journey to becoming a person that is the dominant thread of the first book of the novel. In this, he is guided by Volzotan Smyke, the shark-grub, the first of the many rather bizarre characters Rumo encounters over the course of his journeys. When introducing a new character Moers does something that could be very distracting—he pauses Rumo’s story and tells each new character’s story up to the point they meet Rumo—how they got there and perhaps where they want to go. He even sets out a note in the margins introducing the story each time one is told. These little asides could be detrimental to the overall novel, breaking the flow of the story. However, each character’s story is paid such beautiful and detailed attention that it becomes more than an aside. Even the minor characters have richly detailed and complicated lives and their tales provide essential information in many cases, as these characters will very often re-enter Rumo’s story later on, and their motivations in the present become clear in the light of their past histories. It’s a rather unconventional technique, but it works, in large part because Moers creates such a strong main plot arc that these diversions enrich rather than pull one away from the overall story.
Part of the joy of Rumo’s discovering what it means to be a person is that he becomes a Wolperting person, and not a human person. K.M. Hirosaki, among others, has pointed out that often in furry literature species is simply a “cosmetic veneer” playing little role in advancing either plot or characterization. Moers, though not a furry (as far as I know) makes no such mistake. Being a Wolperting is a unique experience, as is being a shark-grub, a clockwork warrior, or an undead ice yeti. The world of Wolpertings is one filled with marks of personhood—speech, literature, studies, warfare, love, even bureaucracy, but in ways that make each of these things distinctly Wolperting. Moers very effectively is able to convey how Wolpertings use their senses in ways that are radically different from humans or the other people of the continent of Zamonia. My favorite device is that young male Wolpertings follow a “silver thread” of scent when they close their eyes that leads them over hundreds of miles to their future mate.
Walter Moers writing also has a highly humorous style; comparable at times to Lewis Carroll—there are innumerable moments while reading where one is overcome by laughter. This is counterpointed by moments of cruelty and violence however, particularly in book two, where Rumo journeys deep into the underworld and the violence more than anything (but also the vocabulary level and length at 687 pages) make this not a book for children. However, its playfulness and grand adventure style makes it strongly reminiscent of those books we enjoyed as children. The translation of the book from its original German by John Brownjohn is also a strong point. I have not read the original, but the language of the English version is artful, idiomatic, and at no time feels like a translation.
Ultimately, Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures is a very good book. It falls short of being a ‘great’ book in that there are no profound ideas explored, apart from perhaps the already aforementioned choosing to be a person as a child, and it doesn’t make one think in ways that the truly great books do. That said it more than accomplishes what it sets out to do, providing a rollicking and diverting grand adventure. It is a joyful book, a celebration of being alive in a bizarre world. It was difficult to put down, and passes that perhaps greatest test of any book for me—when I finished it I had that feeling of “So now what do I do with my life?”
-Skip Ruddertail
By Walter Moers
Translated from the German by John Brownjohn
2006 The Overlook Press
ISBN: 1-58567-725-6
Since Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures by Walter Moers is a fantasy epic, Rumo, our protagonist, is of course an orphan. In the first book of the novel, he is taken from his home by monsters and imprisoned in a tower, learns to be a warrior, and eventually escapes. In the second book, now grown, he sets out to rescue his love who was kidnapped by forces of evil. This is quite possibly the oldest fantasy plot there is—it certainly seems the most common, but this is not always a bad thing.
In his 1973 interview with documentarian Richard Schickel, Alfred Hitchcock argued that the plots of all his films were at their heart entirely predictable and formulaic—and that the reason the films themselves aren’t repetitive and dull is entirely due to characterization. It is the individuals in these films--their motivations, emotions, impulses and thoughts that make a work unique and indeed alive. Hitchcock so believed in this concept that he coined the term MacGuffin, an item or plot device that is the motivation for the characters in the film, but is of little or no importance to the audience when compared to the actions of the characters themselves.
Though the tools used to create rich and layered characters in film differ from the techniques used in the novel, the central importance of characterization in a work does not, for novels invariably tell the same sorts of tales time and again, and in this Rumo is no different. Fortunately, for all of us, Walter Moers populates Rumo with an endless variety of bizarre and interesting people, who though caught in webs of larger events, pursue their own agendas under the weight of their own emotions, neuroses, and histories. It is the richness of the world and the characters that Moers peoples it with that make Rumo rise above the great mass of fantasy novels.
Moers was a long time comic and graphic novel writer in and illustrator in Germany before he began writing novels set in the fictional continent of Zamonia. He is obviously enjoys a high degree of familiarity with the conventions of the fantasy genre, and he grabs the reader right from the start by turning one such fantasy convention slightly on its side. Like so many fantasy heroes in recent years, Rumo is an orphan (see Harry Potter, Sabriel, The Golden Compass, to name but a few). Authors do this of course so that their young protagonists can act like adults. They are free to make their own choices. One also gets the feeling that authors sometimes make their heroes orphans to do gain a hair more of the reader’s sympathy as well!
Rumo is different from most fantast orphans because his orphan-hood is not tragic, but rather a part of who his people are. Rumo is a Wolperting, half dog-half deer, and looks like a large dog with small horns on his head. Stories of the species are native to Moers’ Germany in the way that tales of jackalopes are told in the Southwestern United States. Wolpertings abandon all their children in forests soon after they are born, and the reason they do this is extraordinary. Some Wolpertings stay wild animals their whole lives, living as dumb beasts in the forest. Others, such as Rumo, make a conscious choice to become people. They decide to walk upright, talk, and eventually make their way to the city of Wolperting. In short sentience is not automatic, but rather a choice. Because of the recognition of this choice, because it had to be done se he could become a Wolperting, Rumo never feels tortured over his lost parents, and this is a rather refreshing change for a book in the fantasy genre. It is simply bad luck that no sooner than Rumo chooses to be a person he is kidnapped by cannibals, taken to their floating island, and the adventure begins in earnest.
It is Rumo’s journey to becoming a person that is the dominant thread of the first book of the novel. In this, he is guided by Volzotan Smyke, the shark-grub, the first of the many rather bizarre characters Rumo encounters over the course of his journeys. When introducing a new character Moers does something that could be very distracting—he pauses Rumo’s story and tells each new character’s story up to the point they meet Rumo—how they got there and perhaps where they want to go. He even sets out a note in the margins introducing the story each time one is told. These little asides could be detrimental to the overall novel, breaking the flow of the story. However, each character’s story is paid such beautiful and detailed attention that it becomes more than an aside. Even the minor characters have richly detailed and complicated lives and their tales provide essential information in many cases, as these characters will very often re-enter Rumo’s story later on, and their motivations in the present become clear in the light of their past histories. It’s a rather unconventional technique, but it works, in large part because Moers creates such a strong main plot arc that these diversions enrich rather than pull one away from the overall story.
Part of the joy of Rumo’s discovering what it means to be a person is that he becomes a Wolperting person, and not a human person. K.M. Hirosaki, among others, has pointed out that often in furry literature species is simply a “cosmetic veneer” playing little role in advancing either plot or characterization. Moers, though not a furry (as far as I know) makes no such mistake. Being a Wolperting is a unique experience, as is being a shark-grub, a clockwork warrior, or an undead ice yeti. The world of Wolpertings is one filled with marks of personhood—speech, literature, studies, warfare, love, even bureaucracy, but in ways that make each of these things distinctly Wolperting. Moers very effectively is able to convey how Wolpertings use their senses in ways that are radically different from humans or the other people of the continent of Zamonia. My favorite device is that young male Wolpertings follow a “silver thread” of scent when they close their eyes that leads them over hundreds of miles to their future mate.
Walter Moers writing also has a highly humorous style; comparable at times to Lewis Carroll—there are innumerable moments while reading where one is overcome by laughter. This is counterpointed by moments of cruelty and violence however, particularly in book two, where Rumo journeys deep into the underworld and the violence more than anything (but also the vocabulary level and length at 687 pages) make this not a book for children. However, its playfulness and grand adventure style makes it strongly reminiscent of those books we enjoyed as children. The translation of the book from its original German by John Brownjohn is also a strong point. I have not read the original, but the language of the English version is artful, idiomatic, and at no time feels like a translation.
Ultimately, Rumo & His Miraculous Adventures is a very good book. It falls short of being a ‘great’ book in that there are no profound ideas explored, apart from perhaps the already aforementioned choosing to be a person as a child, and it doesn’t make one think in ways that the truly great books do. That said it more than accomplishes what it sets out to do, providing a rollicking and diverting grand adventure. It is a joyful book, a celebration of being alive in a bizarre world. It was difficult to put down, and passes that perhaps greatest test of any book for me—when I finished it I had that feeling of “So now what do I do with my life?”
-Skip Ruddertail
Episode 74---Laundry Podcast - Woyro does an update of the latest furry news while doing his laundry at the Whiter Wash Laundrymat in East Rochester, NY.
Woyro does an update of the latest furry news while doing his laundry at the Whiter Wash Laundrymat in East Rochester, NY.
Episode 74---Laundry Podcast - Woyro does an update of the latest furry news while doing his laundry at the Whiter Wash Laundrymat in East Rochester, NY.
Categories: Podcasts
Nurk, the (Somewhat) Brave Little Shrew
Though Harcourt blurbs it as a "first novel," most of us will probably know that artist and author Ursula Vernon (
ursulav) has already published several books, including multiple volumes of her comic/graphic novel Digger and Black Dogs which I take to be intended as the first volume of a series. In one sense, though, Harcourt is correct. Nurk: the Strange, Surprising Adventures of a (Somewhat) Brave Shrew (Harcourt Children's, $15.00, ISBN: 978-0152063757) is written for a juvenile audience, and is Vernon's first published venture in that particular field.
Don't dismiss the book as merely kid stuff, though. The author's droll wit and ironic sense of humor is clearly evident in a manner that will tickle the fancy of the adult reader as well. Nurkus Aurelius Alonzo Electron Maximilian Shrew (no wonder everyone shortens it to just plain "Nurk") is an orphan, having lost his parents when they were eaten by owls (shades of Mervyn Peake's Lord Sepulchrave) under unclear circumstances. He continues to live alone in his family's former home at the base of a large willow tree on the river bank, loosely watched by a great aunt who "looks in" on him once or twice a week. Though he is quite self-sufficient, he yearns to follow the example of his grandmother, Surka Aurelia Maxine Shrew, whose portrait hangs in the front hall of his home. Surka was noted for her ferocious and adventurous nature, evidenced by the fact that the artist portrayed her holding a sword and a severed head in her hands. Nurk isn't quite sure he has the courage to achieve his goal, though, and certainly he has never been far from home.
When a grumpy hummingbird arrives to deliver a letter with a smeared address that appears to direct it to "...URK... UPSTREAM" Nurk assumes it is intended for himself and manages to convince the suspicious bird to hand it over. After he opens it and reads a waterstained plea for help, he realizes that it was in fact intended for none other than Surka, who has been missing for several years and presumed dead. In a quandary for what to do now that he has opened and read a letter never intended for his eyes, and that he can't deliver to the intended recipient, the young shrew seeks advice from his friend the salamander, who tells him to return the letter to the sender. This is easier said than done, since there is no return address or signature. Finally Nurk decides he has no other choice, and prepares for his journey downstream by converting an empty snail shell to a boat and provisioning it suitably, not only with food and drink, but with plenty of clean, dry socks.
Carried by the current, he soon finds himself entangled in any number of small adventures, but the real story unfolds only after he rescues a waterlogged dragonfly princess named Scatterwings. It turns out that Scatterwings herself is the letter writer, and her family needs help to rescue her brother, Prince Flicker, who is being held captive by the Grizzlemole, a blind wizard "half the size of a mountain." I'll let the prospective reader discover the outcome of the quest, the nature of the odd difficulties encountered by Nurk on his way, and the wry witticisms introduced by Vernon as she relates the tale. Naturally, the author has provided the jacket art and internal black and white drawings herself, and they complement the story very well.
I believe this book is deliberately left open for sequels in which we may get to meet Surka Aurelia Maxine Shrew as well, and I look forward to the experience. The fact that Nurk reaches the end of his adventures without using a sword or severing any heads does not reflect badly upon him, and I suspect that his grandmother Surka will eventually be convinced of that too (though perhaps not at first.) While Surka may well resemble the ferocious shrew clans of Brian Jacques' Redwall stories, Nurk has started out more in the character of Kenneth Grahame's Mole, a mild-mannered creature who follows a yearning in his heart and gets much more than he thought he was seeking. I recommend this book to any reader who appreciates small creatures who can get into terrifying situations and yet see the ironic humor of their self-induced plights.
Rating: 4 of 5 possible apples
ursulav) has already published several books, including multiple volumes of her comic/graphic novel Digger and Black Dogs which I take to be intended as the first volume of a series. In one sense, though, Harcourt is correct. Nurk: the Strange, Surprising Adventures of a (Somewhat) Brave Shrew (Harcourt Children's, $15.00, ISBN: 978-0152063757) is written for a juvenile audience, and is Vernon's first published venture in that particular field.When a grumpy hummingbird arrives to deliver a letter with a smeared address that appears to direct it to "...URK... UPSTREAM" Nurk assumes it is intended for himself and manages to convince the suspicious bird to hand it over. After he opens it and reads a waterstained plea for help, he realizes that it was in fact intended for none other than Surka, who has been missing for several years and presumed dead. In a quandary for what to do now that he has opened and read a letter never intended for his eyes, and that he can't deliver to the intended recipient, the young shrew seeks advice from his friend the salamander, who tells him to return the letter to the sender. This is easier said than done, since there is no return address or signature. Finally Nurk decides he has no other choice, and prepares for his journey downstream by converting an empty snail shell to a boat and provisioning it suitably, not only with food and drink, but with plenty of clean, dry socks.
Carried by the current, he soon finds himself entangled in any number of small adventures, but the real story unfolds only after he rescues a waterlogged dragonfly princess named Scatterwings. It turns out that Scatterwings herself is the letter writer, and her family needs help to rescue her brother, Prince Flicker, who is being held captive by the Grizzlemole, a blind wizard "half the size of a mountain." I'll let the prospective reader discover the outcome of the quest, the nature of the odd difficulties encountered by Nurk on his way, and the wry witticisms introduced by Vernon as she relates the tale. Naturally, the author has provided the jacket art and internal black and white drawings herself, and they complement the story very well.
I believe this book is deliberately left open for sequels in which we may get to meet Surka Aurelia Maxine Shrew as well, and I look forward to the experience. The fact that Nurk reaches the end of his adventures without using a sword or severing any heads does not reflect badly upon him, and I suspect that his grandmother Surka will eventually be convinced of that too (though perhaps not at first.) While Surka may well resemble the ferocious shrew clans of Brian Jacques' Redwall stories, Nurk has started out more in the character of Kenneth Grahame's Mole, a mild-mannered creature who follows a yearning in his heart and gets much more than he thought he was seeking. I recommend this book to any reader who appreciates small creatures who can get into terrifying situations and yet see the ironic humor of their self-induced plights.
Rating: 4 of 5 possible apples